“Publishes to HTML5″? Buyer, Beware.

I’ve come across a few rather disturbing instances in the marketing of authoring software lately. I guess it’s not too much of a surprise, since vendors are now pretty much tripping over themselves to deliver content to the iPad (and now all mobile devices), but it’s disturbing nonetheless.

The trend — or maybe it’s too soon to call it a trend, and I hope it doesn’t become one — is that vendors are claiming that their software “publishes to HTML5″, when in fact it just takes the content — which may well be interactive — and publishes it to video. Which pretty much makes it worthless.

I sat in on the HTML5 Morning Buzz at DevLearn and also presented on HTML5 authoring tools (and I will do a longer post on that soon, I promise). I can tell you there’s still a lot of misinformation floating around, and (shocker) it looks like there are some vendors trying to take advantage of it.

I try to keep onehundredfortywords readers pretty well informed about HTML5 in the elearning world, but here’s another point to take to heart: Any authoring tool and any output is only good if it serves your design, which serves the learning/business need. Flawless publishing to HTML5 doesn’t do you any good if the tool isn’t capable of creating — and publishing — the interactivity you’ve designed.

  • http://learnnuggets.com Chief NuggetHead

    Ah, as the battle wages on! Even now with the announcement that Apple is tossing out the Flash player on their devices and focusing their attention to HTML5.

    I was in that morning buzz at DevLearn and there still is a lot (myself included) confusion on what it is and what it can do. Knowing folks like you, Reuben Tozman, and Nick Floro keep me on the straight and narrow. Thanks for keeping your finger on the pulse in this sector!

    • http://onehundredfortywords.com Judy Unrein

      You’re most welcome, Kevin! And you’re right that often it is confusion at work… not an active attempt to spread misinformation. I need to highlight Nick’s and Reuben’s work soon… thanks for the reminder!

  • http://twitter.com/megbertapelle Meg Bertapelle

    AMEN!  I can convert any of our stuff to something that will play as a movie on iOS with tools I already have.  The only “publish to HTML 5″ benefit to me is something that publishes my INTERACTIVE components to HTML 5.  Everything I’ve seen so far has missed some piece of it, but I know it’s a moving target as well.  Adobe’s Captivate converter is still VERY VERY minimal.  Hopefully development moves fast! :)

  • http://www.upsidelearning.com/blog Amit Garg

    Thanks for bringing this up.
    We’ve tried several tools but none of them does the job well enough. What’s unfortunate is some  vendors making false claims which leads to disappointment and certainly does not help adoption of newer technologies.