Not My (Training) Problem

Image of a Phillips head screwdriver trying to connect with a flathead screwAs learning professionals, we often are approached with problems that are really about employees being hired poorly, incentivized inappropriately, managed badly, and not being given good tools for their jobs… in short, things that training can’t fix.

But how often do we actually push back and say, “That’s not a training problem”?

Even among those of us who know better, I suspect the answer is “Not enough”. Maybe we are afraid of being viewed as uncooperative. Maybe we are trying to prove our own value.  Maybe we don’t want to lose the contract or the client. Maybe we just genuinely want to solve the problem.

I don’t have any magic fixes and I’m probably not telling you anything you don’t know.* But I’m encouraging all of us – including me – to more often take a pause to consider this when a project arrives at the door. And if it’s not something your best effort in training can fix, take a breath and try to trust a little more that the person you’re saying No to will value you all the more in the long run for saying it.

* Update: If, on the other hand, this is new information and you don’t know how to determine whether it’s a training problem, this column by Jane Bozarth is a great place to start.

Friends Don’t Let Friends Do Bad Instructional Design

A thought popped into my head this week, as I did my best to fix the work of the instructional designer previously employed by one of my clients…

Ellen Wagner said it in her closing comments at TechKnowledge: Don’t let people do bad instructional design to you.

Here’s what that means to me: Whatever my competitors are doing, that’s what their clients think is elearning. If it’s ineffective, their clients may come to me instead… But just as likely, they may abandon elearning without knowing that there are other options. Do good work, and we all benefit.

How to get there? Four ways come to mind:

1) Learn from whatever sources you can.

2) Be generous with your time when others want advice.

3) Don’t reward others’ bad designs.

4) Do your best work always. Yes, I know… But aim for always.

What else?

Knowledge and Imagination, or Knowledge vs. Imagination?

I’m reading The Philosophical Baby in my free time*, hoping to understand more about the great learning experiment I’m a part of for the upcoming years.

The most profound insight I’ve gleaned so far is that knowledge actually enables imagination, rather than restricting it.

Alison Gopnik:

Conventional wisdom suggests that knowledge and imagination, science and fantasy, are deeply different from one another — even opposites. But…the same abilities that let children learn so much about the world also allow them to change the world…and to imagine alternative worlds that may never exist at all…

I agree instinctively, yet I see counterexamples every day. At what point — and why — does expertise stop enabling imagination, and start preventing us from seeing new ideas?

* That’s why, after reading for one month, I’m bringing you a quote from page 21.